It finishes not with a conclusion, but with a question. Such an ending is unusual enough and thought-provoking enough to spark much controversy and debate.
June 25, Introduction The lady or the tiger? People have been asking themselves this question ever sincewhen Frank Stockton published it in Century magazine. Which overpowers the other, love or jealousy? Can love really go so far as to cause someone agony just to save a life? Can jealousy really go so far as to inflict murder?
The evidence given in the short story strongly suggests that jealousy can and does overwhelm love—that is, that the tiger was behind the right door. Narration The short story The Lady or the Tiger? The basic premise of the story is a king who tries all of his subjects who are accused of crimes the same way: They are let into an arena with two doors.
Behind one door is a ferocious tiger that will rip them to shreds immediately. Behind the other door is a beautiful young lady whom they will be wed to within minutes, regardless of any previous wives. The accused must pick a door, and whatever is behind the door they pick—be it tiger or maiden—decides their fate.
When the king found out, he was furious, and sentenced the young man to choose a door. The princess, terrified over the fate of her love, found out which door the tiger was behind and which door the lady was behind.
In addition, she also found out who the lady behind the door was—a damsel of the court, whom her lover had talked to before on many occasions. The princess was filled with overwhelming angst and jealousy, and spent many nights tossing and turning over what to do.
He spun around and looked at the princess. She pointed to the right door.
Without hesitation, he pivoted and pointed to the right door. And that, my friends, is where the story ends. It is left up to the reader to analyze the princess and her motives and decide which she would point her lover to—the lady whom she despised and could not bear to see him married to, or the tiger which would leave him a bloody, soupy mess.
Confirmation If the lady did indeed come out of the door, why did the princess tell her lover to choose that one?
Instead, she may have believed that if they could not be together in life, they could be together in death. The princess also might have chosen the tiger because she hated the lady her lover might marry.
Because of the hate twisting inside of her, she may have wished the lady as much harm as possible. If killing her lover caused the lady harm, then so be it—she was so barbaric, there was no end to her wrath when it came to things she truly and deeply hated.
The princess wanted the lady to feel the same pain that she would have if the two were wed.
If she pointed him towards the door with the lady behind it, then she would have to see them married. She would see them around town together, and probably meet their children, and live with the fact that she could not be with her lover every day until she died.
If she picked the door with the tiger behind it, however, he would die immediately. She would be sad, yes, but she could get over it more quickly.
Perhaps if she truly loved him, she would do everything in her power to make him as happy as possible, even if that resulted in her own misery. However, the princess appears to act chiefly in her own self-interest.
In starting the affair, she showed complete disregard for societal norms and for how her actions would reflect upon the royal lineage. In the first case, her love overcame the class separation. Yes, the lady behind the door is the practical, logos-driven choice.
However, oftentimes emotion overcomes logic, and in this case the princess was almost certainly swept away by her jealousy. She would do anything to prevent her lover from marrying another woman. His life was at stake, and yet he vested absolute certainty in the princess.
He trusted her to decide which was best for him, and she picked death. She did it for herself, largely, so that she would not have to see him with another woman, and so that woman would be denied the love that the princess was as well.
She did it for him, so that when she died, they could be together in the afterlife. The tiger came out so that the princess could get what she wanted, and so that in the end, her jealousy overcame her love.
Hope you enjoyed it!The Lady and the Tiger Essay Words | 3 Pages Barbaric Princess “The Lady, or The Tiger” by Mr.
Frank R. Stockton has compelled readers for as long as time. The Lady and the Tiger Essay Words | 3 Pages Barbaric Princess “The Lady, or The Tiger” by Mr.
Frank R. Stockton has compelled readers for as long as time. The short story "The Lady, or The Tiger" is written by, "Frank R. This story was one of the most well liked stories of its time.
It was one of the biggest selling stories in , which made him voted as the fifth best living American writer of the time/5(2). The Lady & the Tiger When the story "The Lady or the Tiger" ended, I was left sitting, trying to figure out what happened, what came out of the door he opened, and what I .
The lady or the tiger opinion essay. Kyodan backpack reflective essay. Dissertation database university michigan the lover marguerite duras essay neugarten gender roles essay sam selvon the lonely londoners essay writer philosophischer essay wettbewerb gmc bakers argument against eliminative materialism essays.
Jun 22, · Frank Stockton’s “The Lady or the Tiger”, although published in , remains an exciting and puzzling enigma that is still valued today, perhaps because of its open ending.
It finishes not with a conclusion, but with a question.